Our Morel & Leek Strata with Lemon Thyme Biscuits was a real winner. But, not every recipe that comes from the kitchens of Burp! fares quite as well. Sometimes we hit on a bummer. This is one of those occasions.
It all started when we gathered in the kitchen to come up with an entry for Panini Kathy's Grilled Cheese Pageant (great round-up, btw -- check it out!). Simple, right? Yeah... well...
From the start, I want to be clear that it wasn't so much that this recipe concept TASTED bad. No, on the contrary, it was a delicious combination of flavors. But the concept was lacking in... how shall we say?... elegance... due primarily to a bit of... seepage.
The idea behind the sammich was simple. Let's take classic flavors from Indian cuisine (namely curry, na'an, onion relish, and hot mango chutney) and combine them with a decidedly French flavor (St. Andre cheese) to create the ULTIMATE grilled cheese experience.
First -- the onion chutney (which really IS a great idea).
First, you take one thinly sliced red onion... and add a spritz of lemon juice.
And that's when tragedy strikes. You never really thought about the fact that the St. Andre is a fairly delicate cheese. Or about the fact that it's a triple cream -- so it's heavy on the side of FAT. AND you've now exposed it to a great deal of unnecessary heat.... VOILA!Sadness ensues.
After sufficient mourning time, we pick ourselves back up again and proceed into the kitchen. Surely this grilled cheese sammich concept can be saved... and so, we begin again. Which is what Burp! is all about.
©BURP! Where Food Happens

Kudos for the effort, and very creative sandwich idea!! When I read the ingredients, my mouth watered. I just love Indian food and a panini with those classic flavors sounds excellent to me.
ReplyDeleteOh, no! It sounded like such a delicious idea! All the ingredients should have been delicious together! Too bad about the texture of St. Andre :(
ReplyDeleteawww! it was a very CREATIVE dish, but i'm sorry that it didn't turn out! did you end up re-doing it in the kitchen?
ReplyDeleteOh, I bet it still tasted amazing.
ReplyDeleteMany congrats on the morel victory!! It was a fantastic recipe, way to go!
ReplyDeleteWell, at least the curried naan grilled cheese was a great, creative concept. You've got to give it a second try with another cheese - it's such a good idea.
what a creative twist!
ReplyDeleteBummer about the seepage. I got really excited when I saw the title of your post because it sounded like the best thing ever...glad you're going to try again! And congrats on your win!
ReplyDeleteCongrats on the morel win! I must admit, one of my favorite things about panini grilled cheese sandwiches is the seeping cheese that gets all crispy on the grill. Does that make me weird? Oh, and the onion relish sounds fantastic!
ReplyDeleteI'd be spooning the melted triple off the grill! The idea was good though.
ReplyDeleteWell you win some, and lose some, but the flavor combination does sound divine! Too bad about the seepage! :)
ReplyDeleteOK, so maybe you didn't find it picture perfect, but really it doesn't look so bad. It actually still looks great! You've enticed us with the fusion flavors.
ReplyDeleteMaking my mouth water. Love those onions.
ReplyDeleteBeing kind of a traditionalist, my favorite ever is grilled cheese with tomato on rye. Cheddar is best for standing up to strong flavors, IMHO. try your combo again with cheddar, which won't melt as fast, and I'll bet you'll be delighted!
ReplyDeleteIt's sad because it looks so good.
ReplyDeleteWhat a shame because it looks lovely. :(
ReplyDeleteThat chutney is wonderful! And what a creative sandwich!!
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like it would be delicious! And so creative. Wow. I'm going to have to try this.
ReplyDeleteI love the nan at Trader Joe's! Looks yummy!
ReplyDeleteCongrats on the win.
ReplyDeleteNow that is just completely heavenly. Truly.
ReplyDeleteHey, congrats on a much-deserved win! Kudos and all that.
I'm always too shy to post my failures. Still, your panino was a valiant effort and certainly had potential. Perhaps you should try again with a less melty-creamy cheese?
ReplyDeleteCongrats on your win. It was well deserved. (I did have to give Claire some kudos on her blog though as I thought her macarons were rather clever.)
Oh, gosh -- Claire deserves big kudos for the macarons. Actually, I thought a number of the morel recipes were pretty awesome!
ReplyDeleteWe'll definitely be trying this panino again with a different cheese. I haven't settled in on exactly what kind yet -- but definitely something less melty. The oily-ooze factor on the St. Andre was just too gross. :)
Maybe less of the wet ingredients the next time.Don't give up yet :)
ReplyDeleteMMMMMMM....love it!! Yummie!!!
ReplyDeleteWell you certainly score points with me for outstanding flavor combo! I bet this would taste awesome side by side instead of assembled. I'll have to seek out that cheese; I've never had it. Looking forward to what you come up with next!
ReplyDeleteNaan pannis are a good idea!
ReplyDeleteIt has such promise! It sounds beautiful.....
ReplyDeleteoh my. who cares how it looks--with those flavors, methinks you can't go wrong. how about just a non-grilled curried naan cheese sandwich? bet that would taste spectacular!
ReplyDeleteFirst of all: congrats!
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like a great idea, I'm sure you'll get great results once you revisit it.